Share this article:
Print

Landrieu still deliberating on health-care reform; Vitter already set against it

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by Bigad Shaban / Eyewitness News

Posted on November 21, 2009 at 12:07 AM

Updated Saturday, Nov 21 at 12:21 AM

******

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The House passed its version of health-care reform two weeks ago, and now it's the Senate's turn. Saturday evening will mark a crucial vote on whether the Senate's 10-year, $848 billion plan will be able to move forward. 

Senator David Vitter wants to kill the proposal in the name of introducing several smaller healthcare bills, while Senator Mary Landrieu remained silent Friday on her stance.

Care and compassion for have no limits for grandmother Belinda Mason, which is why she's hoping for serious health-care reform.

"They tried it eight years ago," she said. "And this time I really think that we're going to get it."

Democrats in Washington celebrated the release Thursday of what they see as the answer. But before the more 2,074 page bill can move forward, lawmakers need to lock in at least 60 votes on the Senate floor this Saturday.

"Assuming it goes through tomorrow, healthcare becomes the current topic of debate in the senate and then debate can last for days weeks, even months," said Brian Brox, a political science professor at Tulane University.

Vitter hopes to stop the debate before it even starts.

"I'm very concerned that this is going to push millions of people off of the coverage they have now," said Vitter.

The senator's public words came after a private roundtable discussion with doctors, hospital administrators and small business leaders handpicked by his office --all adamantly against the proposed plan.

"If a bill like this is passed, you're going to see a lot of people going out of business laying people off," said Michael Mitternight, a small business owner in Jefferson Parish. "It's going to be an economy killer."

Landrieu was noticeably silent on Friday. Her press assistant said she's still reviewing the bill and is so far undecided.

"She's allowing her indecision to be used as a bargaining chip," said Brox. "She's using it with the democratic leadership to get other concessions in this bill and other issues in order basically to get her to buy her vote."

Which could translate to amendments relating to hurricane recovery and coastal restoration, added Brox.

In a Thursday radio interview with WGSO, Landrieu hinted she would at least vote to have the bill move onto debate, but said the creation of a government run public option stands in the way of her ultimate approval, even with the provision allowing states to opt out.

"It is a version of a public option," Landrieu said during the interview. "Which is one of my real concerns because I don't support that as it is written, and I'm negotiating very hard to get that provision removed. And if successful we'll be able to support the bill and if not, we will not."

A wide-eyed Mason said she's hoping it will go through. She said her two young grandchildren happen to be her smallest reasons why, as well as the biggest.

"One day they won't have to look back and see that people were not covered [by insurance]."

If the 60 votes are there Saturday night to allow the bill to move forward, Vitter vows to introduce an amendment which would require all members of Congress to be part of the government run public option, no exceptions. Brox said it's not likely to pass with a Democratic majority.

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

HTML is not allowed.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

psychohurricane said on November 21, 2009 at 2:42 AM

This Horrible Bill Can Not Pass! David Vitter Warned You! Wake Up people! p.s. Shame On Mary!

jewelrylady said on November 21, 2009 at 9:25 AM

Mary Landrieu, if you are listening....PLEASE VOTE NO! You are responsible for every line in this bill if you vote yes! You had better KNOW EVERY LINE and be able to anticipate its consequence. What legacy will you leave your children and mine? This is terrorism from within! This bill creates an environment that will absolutely CRIPPLE our nation! "They" have already started limiting cancer screenings - FOR WOMEN - Hello, IS ANYBODY LISTENING????Can anyone in Washington hear us??? READ YOUR BIBLE! Daniel Chapters 10 to 12 - toward the end, times will be worse than ANY TIME BEFORE IN THE HISTORY OF NATIONS...and THIS IS WHAT YOU ARE SETTING IN MOTION...and it all comes down to YOUR VOTE!

under_da_bridge said on November 21, 2009 at 9:28 AM

I am heading to 500 Poydras to protest, who's with me?

popseal said on November 21, 2009 at 9:33 AM

What's the going price for a congressional vote these days, one can never keep up since the vote/price for vote inflation rate is so inconsistant! This is a perfect example why America is in the fix she is in. We have too many corrupt politicians buying and selling votes and too many in the population that waits at the government feed bin for the day's handout.

renokid said on November 21, 2009 at 9:54 AM

We can either pay for universal healthcare up front, or pay fo it piecemeal at our emergency rooms. The fact is our taxes are already paying for those without insurance. the only thing that will change is the insurance companies, and that's why they are bombarding us with horror story commercials. I advise everyone to read the bill, then ask youself "what specifically does it do for me?" Since most people either have no insurance, pay too much for insurance, or don't have enough insurance, the bill isgood for the majority of us.

biggyrat said on November 21, 2009 at 10:07 AM

....Same old Mary...just ask Cleo Fields if you can on her to do the right thing...

under_da_bridge said on November 21, 2009 at 10:22 AM

renokid, Stupid! Stupid! Stupid! You must be a kid because you have no understanding of basic economics. You obviously never had to meet a payroll or manage an organization with a budget. This will be a stake in the heart of all small business. Personally, I would rather keep paying on the back end and keep my freedom. I am making my way to Mary's office at 500 Poydras to protest. Maybe the media will show up but I won't hold my breath.

conniez said on November 21, 2009 at 10:48 AM

Nationalized healthcare is Socialism. There is no debate about that. Why ANY American, would support Socialism is a mystery. Our Republic is a precious, incredible gift bought in blood, from our Founding countrymen... Senator Landrieu, what are you doing? Please don't add to Louisiana's history of corruption (as another politicians has recently done) by accepting a mega-bribe as well as going down in the history books as a Senator who pushed America into Socialism.

conniez said on November 21, 2009 at 10:53 AM

Hi under_da_bridge... I am going to the rally at Vets and Causeway between 11am and 2pm. There is also a rally on the steps of the State Capital in Baton Rouge, as well as the US Capital in Washington. And there is a Million Med March today all across the country. "A physician grassroots movement to re-establish honor, dignity and worth to the medical profession. That its sole mission is to protect the relationship between the doctor and the patient." Keep up the good fight! Yours in Liberty... ConnieZ

catsmit75 said on November 21, 2009 at 10:56 AM

Note to Senator Landrieu........Louisianians have repeatedly and publicly notified you and your co-Senators and Congressmen/women that we are not in favor of health reform legislations currently drafted on the Hill. There is nothing to debate.......which part of "NO" does the Legislative Branch of our government not understand!!!! Show us today that you support us fully and that Louisianians cannot be bought!!!

silverfox3 said on November 21, 2009 at 11:33 AM

Note to Sen. Landrieu: Hundreds (perhaps thousands) of your constituents have contacted your office to demand health care reform. This reform is decades overdue. Please help Louisiana residents by voting YES for the health reform bill.

catsmit75 said on November 21, 2009 at 12:31 PM

I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them. - Thomas Jefferson

appraiser said on November 21, 2009 at 1:30 PM

I just heard Sen. Landrieu has decided to vote YES. This bill is UNAMERICAN and in my opinion so is she. Senator Landrieu needs to read the U.S. Constitution. I hope Mrs. Landrieu knows by voting YES people in this great state will actively campaign against her in the next election. She and every other senator who voted YES needs to lose their jobs. Enough is enough of the back room deals. Do not try to fool the public that you are helping the state by sliding in someting to the bill to get us money for Medicaid when this whole bill will change the face of this country to socialism and ruin our healthcare system. Also, WWL Please run a big story that Sen. Landreiu and James Carville are having a Fundraiser for Harry Reid in New Orleans very soon. According to the Las Vegas Sun this is what is going on. See link http://www.lasvegassun.com/news/2009/nov/20/senator-host-fundraiser-harry-reid-new-orleans/

cajundweeb said on November 21, 2009 at 6:42 PM

We all know that we need to reform the health care system in this country, but you have to wonder how any such reform as is before the Senate would affect health care for Louisiana State employees. Will it pre-empt OGB or would it supplement it? Can SOMEONE answer this question?

ispeeksasiplease said on November 22, 2009 at 8:21 PM

That's what Mary always says leading up to a crucial vote. Same thing that she says in her Senate campaigns. She is studying it and takes the middle of the road. Until it's time to vote. Then, she's always in Harry Reid's hip pocket.