Mike Perlstein / Eyewitness News
Email: | Twitter: @mperlstein

NEWORLEANS- After three weeks of freedom, a juvenile murder suspect released by mistake is back in custody.

Jermeny Marsh was caught Friday and booked with a new charge of carnal knowledge of a juvenile. Marsh, who turned 18 two days after his capture, is now being held without bond as an adult in Orleans Parish Prison.

Marsh had been locked up in the city's juvenile lockup, the Youth Study Center, for more than two years awaiting trial on a charge of second-degree murder.

It was a juvenile murder case, but the district attorney's office said the facts were serious enough for prosecutors to request that Marsh to be tried as an adult.

Marsh was going through hearings in that process known as a 357 transfer when on Aug. 9 he was booked with another charge: battery on a corrections officer.

That second charge, in which Marsh was booked with a municipal misdemeanor, ultimately led to his mistaken release, despite the pending murder case.

Authorities caught the mistake quickly, but Marsh was nowhere to be found immediately after his release.

'The ball was dropped by the criminal justice system,' said Rafael Goyeneche, president of the Metropolitan Crime Commission. 'This case fell through multiple seams. There were multiple mistakes made by multiple entities.'

In the battery case, Marsh was accused of accosting a counselor at the city's Youth Study Center while the two were inside of his jail cell.

A police report about the altercation states that Marsh pushed and bumped the counselor, telling him, 'F--- you. I run this up in here.'

Police were called and Marsh, then 17, was taken to Orleans Parish Prison to be booked as an adult. Records show he was booked with 'battery of a correctional facility employee.'

The decision to book Marsh with a municipal charge was possibly the first slip-up in the case. State law dictates that when the offender booked with that charge is inmate, the charge is a felony, which would have automatically shifted the case to state court.

'Because this type of battery puts a corrections officer at risk, it is a step up and has the potential to be charged as felony,' Goyeneche said. 'That wasn't done in this case.'

With Marsh's arrest Friday, that case has now been moved to state court as a felony. Bail has not been set in the adult case.

When Marsh was facing only a low-level misdemeanor version of the battery charge, his bail was set at $2,500. Records show it was set by an ad hoc municipal court judge on a Sunday, depriving authorities of another opportunity to keep Marsh behind bars.

If the bail hearing would have taken place during a regular weekday court session, a prosecutor would have been present to flag the case and request a detainer.

But there was no prosecutor in court when Marsh was given his ticket out of jail.

Matt Dennis, of Steve's Bail Bonds, processed Marsh's bond as a routine case.

'It was run of the mill. The kid was booked on a misdemeanor charge, we did the bond and he gets out. That's what happened,' Dennis said.

Dennis said nothing in Marsh's paperwork showed he was supposed to be returned to jail on the murder charge.

'Now we find out there was miscommunication between one facility and another and he wasn't supposed to be released,' Dennis said.

Court paperwork shows that Marsh was taken from the Youth Study Center to Central Lockup, where he remained locked up for two days before his bail hearing.

Neither lockup placed a hold on Marsh, although both have the authority to do so.

The city, which runs the Youth Study Center, did not respond to calls for comment. A spokesman for Orleans Parish Sheriff's Office said that office did nothing wrong.

Chief Municipal Court Judge Desiree Charbonnet said the poor communication between different agencies in the criminal justice system contributed to the oversight.

'I think it's unfortunate that a defendant facing a murder charge was released by mistake, but I honestly can't tell you where the ball was dropped,' Charbonnet said. 'I can tell you that because different parts of the system use different computers, we aren't always able to share information. But in this case, Municipal Court was not aware that this young man was facing a murder charge.'

Read or Share this story: